Long Island Restaurants

Italian food on Long Island

Nassau and Suffolk counties are home to about 1,500 restaurants that identify themselves as Italian, according to Dun and Bradstreet. And there are Italian restaurants to suit every mood, palate and wallet. We ate our way across Long Island to narrow the field to our 40 favorites, and found the restaurants that prepared popular dishes the best. Buon appetito!

Our favorite Italian restaurants in Nassau

Our favorite Italian restaurants in Nassau

"People will like a restaurant because their mom made great meatballs and this restaurant makes great meatballs that taste like mom's." -- John Durkin, Trattoria Diane 
Our favorite Italian restaurants in Suffolk

Our favorite Italian restaurants in Suffolk

"If a customer doesn't take something home, your portions are too small" -- Guy Lombardi, Mamma Lombardi's 
A shoutout to neighborhood favorites

A shoutout to neighborhood favorites

Let's not forget the local family-friendly spaghetti houses and trattorias. 
Our picks for best dishes -- and where to get them

Our picks for best dishes -- and where to get them

Everyone has a favorite Italian dish. Here are ones we liked best. 
Wine pairings for your favorite Italian meals

Wine pairings for your favorite Italian meals

Generally, wines should either complement or contrast with food. Here are some recommendations. 
Long Island Italian restaurants FAQ

Long Island Italian restaurants FAQ

So exactly what IS Italian? 
Criteria used in formulating this list

Criteria used in formulating this list

We didn't compare apples and arancini. Here's how we came up with the top 40. 

Italian cooking class

Talk about it
Tell us about your favorite Italian restaurants -- and get recommendations of readers' favorites.

Quiz

Poll
How often do you go to an Italian restaurant?
More than once a week
Once a week
Once a month
Rarely

Long Island's best pizza

We ate our way across Nassau and Suffolk and found the top 10 slices.