Long Island Restaurants







Restaurant Reviews



Enter restaurant name (optional)


Best casual eats on LI

Ice cream
Diners
Delis
Pizza
Burgers
Hot dogs
Chain restaurants
Cheap eats

Feed Me: Latest posts

Event Search
Select event type
Choose area

Narrow by date

Keyword (optional):


Theater Search
Select event type
Narrow by date

Keyword (optional):


Keyword Search
Keyword:


Mamma Lombardi's

 
View larger map/directions
400 Furrows Rd.
Holbrook, NY 11741
631-737-0774

Mamma Lombardi's is the unofficial capital of Tomatoland. On an island awash in red sauce, this is one of the big waves.

It's an Italian restaurant with its soul in Naples and points south. The eatery is buoyant, crowded, kitschy, brusque, efficient ... and very good.

The best advice here is the simplest: eat whatever you like. The kitchen is remarkably consistent. The seafood salad is terrific, the stuffed artichokes and stuffed peppers generous, eggplant rollatine addictive, and all the husky pastas textbook versions.

Heat-seekers will be especially fond of the fiery penne arrabiata, which is angry in the extreme. Manicotti are mandatory, holding enough ricotta to feed two. The place prepares spaghetti alla carbonara with equal aplomb.

Chicken with sausage and potatoes and peppers is a gutsy campagnola. Tripe in red sauce: soulful stuff. And the beef braciola is excellent, packed with pine nuts, raisins, garlic and flavor. Mamma Lombardi's also is the eatery for pork chops with vinegar peppers and lobster fra diavolo.

Finish with cannoli, espresso and satisfaction.

Peter M. Gianotti

Hours

Dinner every day. Lunch, Monday to Saturday.

Assessment

Sunday dinner.

Cuisine

Italian

Directions

Four traffic lights south of Long Island Expressway exit 61.

Major Credit Cards Accepted

All major cards.

Price Range

Expensive ($25-$50)

Rating

Very Good (2 stars)

Reservations

Recommended

Special Features

Open for Lunch/Brunch, Good for Parties/Large Groups, Business Lunch/Dinner, Suitable for Young Children

Wheelchair Access

One level.