Long Island Restaurants









Restaurant Reviews



Enter restaurant name (optional)


Best casual eats on LI

Ice cream
Diners
Delis
Pizza
Burgers
Hot dogs
Chain restaurants
Cheap eats

Feed Me: Latest posts

Event Search
Select event type
Choose area

Narrow by date

Keyword (optional):


Theater Search
Select event type
Narrow by date

Keyword (optional):


Keyword Search
Keyword:


Pancho's Border Grill

 
View larger map/directions
4119 Hempstead Tpke
Bethpage, NY 11714-5605
516-579-5500

Although its name sounds generic and it's actually the third link in a small Long Island chainlet, Pancho's Border Grill in Bethpage is an original of sorts. How many margarita joints do you know where the food is better than the drinks? And they do make a mean margarita.

The quality of fare is evident in the bright, chunky cilantro-spiked salsa; you'll dip many nacho chips. The music of the Grateful Dead plays on the sound system, and the walls of the place are covered with license plates from all over the USA.

At lunch, a delightful salad of mesclun greens comes topped with marinated skirt steak and sliced chicken, dressed with a dandy buttermilk chipotle dressing. A catfish po' boy sandwich with chiptole tarter sauce comes with fine sweet potato fries.

Appetizer platters are messy fun. The tidbit platter includes crisp, greaseless chicken fingers, meaty barbecued riblets and chicken wings, and good quesadillas.

Fajitas - to some, the measure of a Tex-Mex eatery - feature juicy, well-marinated steak and chicken; my quibble was that the pico de gallo of jalapenos and tomatoes does not have enough cilantro, and that it, as well as the guacamole, comes in a tiny paper thimble.

Desserts are house-made and served with freshly whipped cream. You must get the definitive flan, creamier than most. Ask what the secret ingredient is.

By Joan Reminick

Hours

Lunch, Tuesday to Friday; dinner, Tuesday through Sunday. Closed Monday.

Assessment

Zippy Tex-Mex food with flair.

Cuisine

Tex-Mex

Major Credit Cards Accepted

Yes

Price Range

Inexpensive (Under $15), Moderate ($15-$25)

Reservations

Not Accepted

Special Features

Open for Lunch/Brunch, Suitable for Young Children, Offbeat/Quirky

Wheelchair Access

Restrooms not fully accessible.